If You Liked Midnight Mass, Watch These Next
Finished Midnight Mass (2021) and want more of the same? These 20 TV shows are what its fans watched next, ranked by how often people who liked it also liked these. Like Midnight Mass, most of them are mystery, drama.
Everything on this page has a home release and plays right here on Rotten Brains — pick one and press play. No sign-up, and a free account only adds resume and history.
20 titles · updated 3rd October 2026
1.Evil(2019)
7.8CrimeDramaMysteryAlso drama and mystery
Skeptical forensic psychologist Kristen Bouchard joins priest-in-training David Acosta and technology expert Ben Shakir as they investigate supposed miracles, demonic possessions, and other extraordinary occurrences to assess for a scientific explanation or if something truly supernatural is at work.
Watch from S1 E1
2.Grotesquerie(2024)
7.3DramaMysteryCrimeAlso drama and mystery
A series of heinous crimes have unsettled a small community, and Detective Lois Tryon feels they are eerily personal, as if someone—or something—is taunting her.
Watch from S1 E1
3.The Exorcist(2016)
7.3MysteryDramaAlso mystery and drama
Follow the lives of two very different priests tackling one family’s case of terrifying demonic possession.
Watch from S1 E1
4.Harper's Island(2009)
6.9MysteryDramaAlso mystery and drama
A group of family and friends travels to a secluded island for a destination wedding. They've come to laugh... to love... and, though they don't know it... to die. As the wedding festivities begin, friendships are tested and secrets exposed as a murderer claims victims, one by one, transforming the wedding week of…
Watch from S1 E1
5.Twin Peaks(1990)
8.3DramaMysteryAlso drama and mystery
The body of Laura Palmer is washed up on a beach near the small Washington state town of Twin Peaks. FBI Special Agent Dale Cooper is called in to investigate her strange demise only to uncover a web of mystery that ultimately leads him deep into the heart of the surrounding woodland and his very own soul.
Watch from S1 E1
6.Sterling Point(2026)
8.2MysteryDramaAlso mystery and drama
After discovering she's inherited a remote island in Canada from the estranged grandfather she was never allowed to meet, 17-year-old Annie Jacobson decides to investigate, pulling her into a world of buried secrets, unexpected sisterhood, and the complicated family history she was never meant to find.
Watch from S1 E1
7.Inside Man(2022)
6.9DramaCrimeMysteryAlso drama and mystery
A prisoner on death row in the US, a vicar in a quiet English town, and a maths teacher trapped in a cellar cross paths in the most unexpected way.
Watch from S1 E1
8.Sleepy Hollow(2013)
7.4DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
Ichabod Crane is resurrected and pulled two and a half centuries through time to unravel a mystery that dates all the way back to the founding fathers.
Watch from S1 E1
9.FROM(2022)
8.5MysteryDramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso mystery and drama
Unravel the mystery of a nightmarish town in middle America that traps all those who enter. As the unwilling residents fight to keep a sense of normalcy and search for a way out, they must also survive the threats of the surrounding forest – including the terrifying creatures that come out when the sun goes down.
Watch from S1 E1
10.The Burning Girls(2023)
6.9MysteryDramaAlso mystery and drama
Follows Reverend Jack Brooks and her daughter in Chapel Croft, a place for a fresh start that soon reveals its community's dark history and where ancient superstitions and mistrust of outsiders are quite common.
Watch from S1 E1
11.Grantchester(2014)
7.3CrimeDramaMysteryAlso drama and mystery
In 1953 at the hamlet of Grantchester, Sidney Chambers—a charismatic, charming clergyman—turns investigative vicar when one of his parishioners dies in suspicious circumstances.
Watch from S1 E1
12.Sugar(2024)
7.1DramaMysteryAlso drama and mystery
John Sugar is a dashing private eye navigating the dark corners of sunny LA. Though he sees only the good in humanity, Sugar is haunted by a secret too dangerous to expose.
Watch from S1 E1
13.The Sinner(2017)
7.5CrimeDramaAlso drama
In a small New York town, a haunted detective hunts for answers about perplexing crimes while wrestling with his own demons.
Watch from S1 E1
14.Scrublands(2023)
7.0DramaCrimeAlso drama
In a small town, a priest opens fire on his congregation, killing five parishioners. One year later, a journalist arrives to investigate the tragedy, and after digging beneath the surface finds himself in a life-and-death race to uncover the truth.
Watch from S1 E1
15.Disclaimer(2024)
7.5DramaMysteryAlso drama and mystery
When an intriguing novel appears at the bedside of a journalist whose career has been built on revealing transgressions, she is horrified to realize she's a key character in a long-buried story—one that exposes her darkest secret.
Watch from S1 E1
16.Dark Winds(2022)
7.5DramaCrimeMysteryAlso drama and mystery
This psychological thriller follows two Navajo police officers, Leaphorn and Chee, in the 1970s Southwest as their search for clues in a grisly double murder case forces them to challenge their own spiritual beliefs and come to terms with the trauma of their pasts.
Watch from S1 E1
17.Chapelwaite(2021)
7.3DramaMysteryAlso drama and mystery
In the 1850s, Captain Charles Boone relocates his family of three children to his ancestral home in the small, seemingly sleepy town of Preacher’s Corners, Maine after his wife dies at sea. Charles will soon have to confront the secrets of his family’s sordid history, and fight to end the darkness that has plagued…
Watch from S1 E1
18.Glitch(2015)
6.8DramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama
A police officer and a doctor face an emotionally charged mystery when seven local residents inexplicably return from the dead in peak physical form.
Watch from S1 E1
19.Salem's Lot(2004)
6.0DramaMysteryAlso drama and mystery
A dark terror has come to the picture-perfect town of Jerusalem's Lot, and it's up to a writer with a haunted past to uncover the horror that has taken over the town.
Watch from S1 E1
20.Lost(2004)
8.0MysteryAction & AdventureDramaAlso mystery and drama
Stripped of everything, the survivors of a horrific plane crash must work together to stay alive. But the island holds many secrets.
Watch from S1 E1