If You Liked Sleepy Hollow, Watch These Next
Finished Sleepy Hollow (2013) and want more of the same? These 20 TV shows are what its fans watched next, ranked by how often people who liked it also liked these. Like Sleepy Hollow, most of them are drama, mystery, sci-fi & fantasy.
Everything on this page has a home release and plays right here on Rotten Brains — pick one and press play. No sign-up, and a free account only adds resume and history.
20 titles · updated 2nd October 2026
1.Grimm(2011)
8.3DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
After Portland homicide detective Nick Burkhardt discovers he's descended from an elite line of criminal profilers known as "Grimms," he increasingly finds his responsibilities as a detective at odds with his new responsibilities as a Grimm.
Watch from S1 E1
2.Continuum(2012)
7.5Sci-Fi & FantasyAction & AdventureDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
The series centers on the conflict between a group of rebels from the year 2077 who time-travel to Vancouver, BC, in 2012, and a police officer who accidentally accompanies them. In spite of being many years early, the rebel group decides to continue its violent campaign to stop corporations of the future from…
Watch from S1 E1
3.FROM(2022)
8.5MysteryDramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso mystery and drama
Unravel the mystery of a nightmarish town in middle America that traps all those who enter. As the unwilling residents fight to keep a sense of normalcy and search for a way out, they must also survive the threats of the surrounding forest – including the terrifying creatures that come out when the sun goes down.
Watch from S1 E1
4.American Gods(2017)
7.1DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
An ex-con becomes the traveling partner of a conman who turns out to be one of the older gods trying to recruit troops to battle the upstart deities. Based on Neil Gaiman's fantasy novel.
Watch from S1 E1
5.Wayward Pines(2015)
6.9DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
Imagine the perfect American town... beautiful homes, manicured lawns, children playing safely in the streets. Now imagine never being able to leave. You have no communication with the outside world. You think you're going insane. You must be in Wayward Pines.
Watch from S1 E1
6.Millennium(1996)
7.7CrimeDramaMysteryAlso drama and mystery
A retired FBI serial-profiler joins the mysterious Millennium Group, a team of underground ex-law enforcement experts dedicated to fighting against the ever-growing forces of evil and darkness in the world.
Watch from S1 E1
7.Carnival Row(2019)
7.7CrimeDramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
In a mystical and dark city filled with humans, fairies and other creatures, a police detective investigates a series of gruesome murders leveled against the fairy population. During his investigation, the detective becomes the prime suspect and must find the real killer to clear his name.
Watch from S1 E1
8.Fringe(2008)
8.1Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaMysteryAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
FBI Special Agent Olivia Dunham, brilliant but formerly institutionalized scientist Walter Bishop and his scheming, reluctant son Peter uncover a deadly mystery involving a series of unbelievable events and realize they may be a part of a larger, more disturbing pattern that blurs the line between science fiction and…
Watch from S1 E1
9.Salem(2014)
7.3Sci-Fi & FantasyMysteryDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and mystery
Set in the volatile world of 17th century Massachusetts, 'Salem' explores what really fueled the town's infamous witch trials and dares to uncover the dark, supernatural truth hiding behind the veil of this infamous period in American history. In Salem, witches are real, but they are not who or what they seem.
Watch from S1 E1
10.Shadow and Bone(2021)
7.7DramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
In a world cleaved in two by a massive barrier of perpetual darkness, a young soldier uncovers a power that might finally unite her country. But as she struggles to hone her power, dangerous forces plot against her. Thugs, thieves, assassins and saints are at war now, and it will take more than magic to survive.
Watch from S1 E1
11.The X-Files(1993)
8.4MysterySci-Fi & FantasyCrimeAlso mystery and sci-fi & fantasy
The exploits of FBI Special Agents Fox Mulder and Dana Scully who investigate X-Files: marginalized, unsolved cases involving paranormal phenomena. Mulder believes in the existence of aliens and the paranormal while Scully, a skeptic, is assigned to make scientific analyses of Mulder's discoveries that debunk…
Watch from S1 E1
12.Class of '09(2023)
7.1DramaMysteryCrimeAlso drama and mystery
Set in three distinct points in time, follow a class of FBI agents who grapple with immense changes as the U.S. criminal justice system is altered by artificial intelligence.
Watch from S1 E1
13.Glitch(2015)
6.8DramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
A police officer and a doctor face an emotionally charged mystery when seven local residents inexplicably return from the dead in peak physical form.
Watch from S1 E1
14.The Leftovers(2014)
7.7Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
When 2% of the world's population abruptly disappears without explanation, the world struggles to understand just what they're supposed to do about it. This is the story of the people who didn't make the cut.
Watch from S1 E1
15.The Purge(2018)
6.9MysteryCrimeDramaAlso mystery and drama
Set in a dystopian America ruled by a totalitarian political party, the series follows several seemingly unrelated characters living in a small city. Tying them all together is a mysterious savior who’s impeccably equipped for everything the night throws at them. As the clock winds down with their fates hanging in…
Watch from S1 E1
16.Emergence(2019)
6.9DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
A police chief takes in a young child she finds near the site of a mysterious accident who has no memory of what has happened. The investigation draws her into a conspiracy larger than she ever imagined, and the child’s identity is at the center of it all.
Watch from S1 E1
17.Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.(2013)
7.5DramaSci-Fi & FantasyAction & AdventureAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
Agent Phil Coulson of S.H.I.E.L.D. (Strategic Homeland Intervention, Enforcement and Logistics Division) puts together a team of agents to investigate the new, the strange and the unknown around the globe, protecting the ordinary from the extraordinary.
Watch from S1 E1
18.Superstition(2017)
5.9Sci-Fi & FantasyMysteryDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and mystery
The Mosley family keeps the secrets and dark history of a town located on the outskirts of New Orleans that is also a landing patch for the world's darkest manifestations of fear, guided into the world by a mysterious malefactor named The Dredge.
Watch from S1 E1
19.Twin Peaks(1990)
8.3DramaMysteryAlso drama and mystery
The body of Laura Palmer is washed up on a beach near the small Washington state town of Twin Peaks. FBI Special Agent Dale Cooper is called in to investigate her strange demise only to uncover a web of mystery that ultimately leads him deep into the heart of the surrounding woodland and his very own soul.
Watch from S1 E1
20.Midnight Mass(2021)
7.6MysteryDramaAlso mystery and drama
The arrival of a charismatic young priest brings glorious miracles, ominous mysteries and renewed religious fervor to a dying town desperate to believe.
Watch from S1 E1