If You Liked American Gods, Watch These Next
Finished American Gods (2017) and want more of the same? These 20 TV shows are what its fans watched next, ranked by how often people who liked it also liked these. Like American Gods, most of them are drama, mystery, sci-fi & fantasy.
Everything on this page has a home release and plays right here on Rotten Brains — pick one and press play. No sign-up, and a free account only adds resume and history.
20 titles · updated 3rd October 2026
1.Lovecraft Country(2020)
7.1DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
The anthology horror series follows 25-year-old Atticus Freeman, who joins up with his friend Letitia and his Uncle George to embark on a road trip across 1950s Jim Crow America to find his missing father. They must survive and overcome both the racist terrors of white America and the malevolent spirits that could be…
Watch from S1 E1
2.Emergence(2019)
6.9DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
A police chief takes in a young child she finds near the site of a mysterious accident who has no memory of what has happened. The investigation draws her into a conspiracy larger than she ever imagined, and the child’s identity is at the center of it all.
Watch from S1 E1
3.Sleepy Hollow(2013)
7.4DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
Ichabod Crane is resurrected and pulled two and a half centuries through time to unravel a mystery that dates all the way back to the founding fathers.
Watch from S1 E1
4.Helstrom(2020)
6.7Action & AdventureSci-Fi & FantasyDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
Daimon and Ana Helstrom are the son and daughter of a mysterious and powerful serial killer. The siblings have a complicated dynamic as they track down the terrorizing worst of humanity — each with their attitude and skills.
Watch from S1 E1
5.Silo(2023)
8.2Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
In a ruined and toxic future, thousands live in a giant silo deep underground. After its sheriff breaks a cardinal rule and residents die mysteriously, engineer Juliette starts to uncover shocking secrets and the truth about the silo.
Watch from S1 E1
6.The Rig(2023)
6.6DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
When the crew of the Kinloch Bravo find themselves cut off from all communication with the Scottish mainland by a mysterious fog, they must fight to find a way home whilst managing environmental pressures, mounting paranoia and rising tensions. But as the threat facing them reveals itself to be something beyond their…
Watch from S1 E1
7.NOS4A2(2019)
7.3Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
A young Victoria "Vic" McQueen discovers she has the power to unlock portals that help her find lost objects. As she delves further into this hidden universe, she encounters many other "inscape travelers" - some benevolent, and some who have been corrupted by their power. When Vic encounters Charlie Manx, an immortal…
Watch from S1 E1
8.American Horror Stories(2021)
7.7DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
An anthology series of stand alone episodes delving into horror myths, legends and lore.
Watch from S1 E1
9.The Wheel of Time(2021)
7.6Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
The lives of five young villagers change forever when a strange and powerful woman arrives, claiming one of them is the child of an ancient prophecy with the power to tip the balance between Light and Dark forever. They must choose whether to trust this stranger – and each other – with the fate of the world before…
Watch from S1 E1
10.From Dusk Till Dawn: The Series(2014)
6.4CrimeSci-Fi & FantasyDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
The horror and crime thriller genres collide in this new original series from Robert Rodriguez, based on his cult grindhouse classic about bank-robbing brothers on the run, a lawman bent on bringing them to justice, the devout family caught in the cross-fire, and an ancient evil eager to feast on them all.
Watch from S1 E1
11.Millennium(1996)
7.7CrimeDramaMysteryAlso drama and mystery
A retired FBI serial-profiler joins the mysterious Millennium Group, a team of underground ex-law enforcement experts dedicated to fighting against the ever-growing forces of evil and darkness in the world.
Watch from S1 E1
12.Wayward Pines(2015)
6.9DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
Imagine the perfect American town... beautiful homes, manicured lawns, children playing safely in the streets. Now imagine never being able to leave. You have no communication with the outside world. You think you're going insane. You must be in Wayward Pines.
Watch from S1 E1
13.Lisey's Story(2021)
6.1MysteryDramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso mystery and drama
This terrifying thriller follows widow Lisey Landon as a series of disturbing events revives memories of her marriage to author Scott Landon and the darkness that plagued him.
Watch from S1 E1
14.Grimm(2011)
8.3DramaMysterySci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and mystery
After Portland homicide detective Nick Burkhardt discovers he's descended from an elite line of criminal profilers known as "Grimms," he increasingly finds his responsibilities as a detective at odds with his new responsibilities as a Grimm.
Watch from S1 E1
15.Outcast(2016)
7.1MysteryDramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso mystery and drama
Kyle Barnes has been plagued by possession since he was a child. Now an adult, he embarks on a spiritual journey to find answers, but what he uncovers could mean the end of life on Earth as we know it.
Watch from S1 E1
16.The Sandman(2022)
7.8Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaAction & AdventureAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
After years of imprisonment, Morpheus — the King of Dreams — embarks on a journey across worlds to find what was stolen from him and restore his power.
Watch from S1 E1
17.Preacher(2016)
7.4Sci-Fi & FantasyMysteryDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and mystery
A preacher sets out on a mission to make the almighty himself confess his sin of abandoning the world. With his best friend Cassidy, an alcoholic Irish vampire, his love Tulip, a red blooded gun towing Texan, and the power of genesis, an unholy child born from an angel and a devil, Jesse gives up everything to set…
Watch from S1 E1
18.Penny Dreadful: City of Angels(2020)
6.8Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaCrimeAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
Rooted in the conflict between characters connected to the deity Santa Muerte and others allied with the Devil, this saga explores an exciting mix of the supernatural and the combustible reality of 1938 Los Angeles, a time and place deeply infused with Mexican-American folklore and social tension.
Watch from S1 E1
19.Midnight, Texas(2017)
7.4Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
Welcome to a place where being normal is really quite strange. In a remote Texas town no one is who they seem. From vampires and witches to psychics and hit men, Midnight is a mysterious safe haven for those who are different. As the town members fight off outside pressures from rowdy biker gangs, ever-suspicious…
Watch from S1 E1
20.Tales from the Loop(2020)
7.0Sci-Fi & FantasyMysteryDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and mystery
The story of the town and people who live above “The Loop,” a machine built to unlock and explore the mysteries of the universe – making things possible that were previously relegated only to science fiction.
Watch from S1 E1