If You Liked Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Watch These Next
Finished Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1997) and want more of the same? These 19 TV shows are what its fans watched next, ranked by how often people who liked it also liked these. Like Buffy the Vampire Slayer, most of them are comedy, drama, sci-fi & fantasy.
Everything on this page has a home release and plays right here on Rotten Brains — pick one and press play. No sign-up, and a free account only adds resume and history.
19 titles · updated 2nd October 2026
1.Charmed(1998)
8.2ComedyDramaMysteryAlso comedy and drama
Three sisters (Prue, Piper and Phoebe) reunite and unlock their powers to become the Charmed Ones, the most powerful good witches of all time, whose prophesied destiny is to protect innocent lives from evil beings such as demons and warlocks. Each sister possesses unique magical powers that grow and evolve, while…
Watch from S1 E1
2.Nancy Drew(2019)
7.7MysteryDramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
Nancy Drew makes plans to leave her hometown for college, but finds herself drawn into a supernatural murder mystery instead.
Watch from S1 E1
3.Hex(2004)
6.5Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
Shy college student Cassie Hughes only wants to be accepted by others, but is only truly loved by her best friend Thelma Bates. Cassie later discovers that she possesses dangerous powers, and is being drawn into a world far beyond her control. And the man that she should fear the most manages to find a way into her…
Watch from S1 E1
4.DC's Stargirl(2020)
7.7Sci-Fi & FantasyAction & AdventureDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
Courtney Whitmore, a smart, athletic and above all else kind girl, discovers her step-father has a secret: he used to be the sidekick to a superhero. "Borrowing" the long-lost hero’s cosmic staff, she becomes the unlikely inspiration for an entirely new generation of superheroes.
Watch from S1 E1
5.Marvel's Runaways(2017)
7.3Action & AdventureDramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
Every teenager thinks their parents are evil. What if you found out they actually were? Six diverse teenagers who can barely stand each other must unite against a common foe – their parents.
Watch from S1 E1
6.Birds of Prey(2002)
6.2DramaAction & AdventureSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
The series is set in New Gotham City, several years after it has been apparently abandoned by Batman. In his absence, Huntress, Oracle and Dinah are now the protectors of New Gotham: the Birds of Prey, and had taken over his war on crime. They are joined by Alfred Pennyworth, who serves Helena as she is heir to the…
Watch from S1 E1
7.WandaVision(2021)
8.2Sci-Fi & FantasyMysteryDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
Wanda Maximoff and Vision—two super-powered beings living idealized suburban lives—begin to suspect that everything is not as it seems.
Watch from S1 E1
8.A Discovery of Witches(2018)
7.8Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
Closet witch Diana Bishop and centuries-old vampire Matthew Clairmont are drawn into a deadly mystery and forbidden romance when a magical book shows up in an Oxford library.
Watch from S1 E1
9.Willow(2022)
6.6Sci-Fi & FantasyAction & AdventureDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
Many years after the events of the original film, legendary sorcerer Willow leads a group of misfit heroes on a dangerous rescue mission through a world beyond their wildest imaginations.
Watch from S1 E1
10.Carmilla(2014)
7.9DramaComedyAlso drama and comedy
Laura Hollis, a newly enrolled college student at Silas University, shares a room with Betty, who mysteriously disappears all of a sudden. Little does Laura know that after this fateful night, nothing will be the same in her life, starting with meeting her new roommate from hell, Carmilla Karnstein. "Carmilla" is a…
Watch from S1 E1
11.She-Hulk: Attorney at Law(2022)
6.1ComedySci-Fi & FantasyAlso comedy and sci-fi & fantasy
Jennifer Walters navigates the complicated life of a single, 30-something attorney who also happens to be a green 6-foot-7-inch superpowered hulk.
Watch from S1 E1
12.Naomi(2022)
5.9DramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
Follow a teen girl’s journey from her small northwestern town to the heights of the multiverse. When a supernatural event shakes her hometown to the core, Naomi sets out to uncover its origins, and what she discovers will challenge everything we believe about our heroes
Watch from S1 E1
13.The Magicians(2015)
7.6DramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
Brakebills University is a secret institution specializing in magic. There, amidst an unorthodox education of spellcasting, a group of twenty-something friends soon discover that a magical fantasy world they read about as children is all too real— and poses grave danger to humanity.
Watch from S1 E1
14.Charmed(2018)
7.2DramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
Set in the fictional college town of Hilltowne, Charmed follows the lives of three sisters, Macy, Mel and Maggie Vera who, after the tragic death of their mother, discover they are three of the most powerful witches of all time.
Watch from S1 E1
15.Moonlight(2007)
7.3MysteryCrimeDramaAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
Mick St. John is a captivating, charming and immortal private investigator from Los Angeles, who defies the traditional blood-sucking norms of his vampire tendencies by using his wit and powerful supernatural abilities to help the living.
Watch from S1 E1
16.Highlander: The Series(1992)
7.4Sci-Fi & FantasyDramaAction & AdventureAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
Duncan MacLeod cannot die -- he is a 400-year-old immortal, who has seen his share of humanity's history. Still, he risks his life in battle against other immortals and tries to save people from harm.
Watch from S1 E1
17.Supergirl(2015)
7.3DramaSci-Fi & FantasyAction & AdventureAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
Twenty-four-year-old Kara Zor-El, who was taken in by the Danvers family when she was 13 after being sent away from Krypton, must learn to embrace her powers after previously hiding them. The Danvers teach her to be careful with her powers, until she has to reveal them during an unexpected disaster, setting her on…
Watch from S1 E1
18.The Flash(2014)
7.7DramaSci-Fi & FantasyAlso drama and sci-fi & fantasy
After being struck by lightning, CSI investigator Barry Allen awakens from a nine-month coma to discover he has been granted the gift of super speed. Teaming up with S.T.A.R. Labs, Barry takes on the persona of The Flash, the Fastest Man Alive, to protect his city.
Watch from S1 E1
19.South of Hell(2015)
6.4MysterySci-Fi & FantasyDramaAlso sci-fi & fantasy and drama
A supernatural thriller set in South Carolina, South Of Hell focuses on Maria Abascal (Suvari), a stunning demon-hunter-for-hire whose power stems from within. Like those she hunts, Maria is divided within herself, struggling with her own demon, Abigail, who resides inside of her, feeding on the evil Maria exorcises…
Watch from S1 E1