If You Liked Extraordinary Tales, Watch These Next
Finished Extraordinary Tales (2015) and want more of the same? These 17 movies are what its fans watched next, ranked by how often people who liked it also liked these. Like Extraordinary Tales, most of them are horror, animation, mystery.
Everything on this page has a home release and plays right here on Rotten Brains — pick one and press play. No sign-up, and a free account only adds resume and history.
17 titles · updated 3rd October 2026
1.Something Wicked This Way Comes(1983)
6.5FantasyMysteryHorrorAlso mystery and horror
In a small American town, a diabolical circus arrives, granting wishes for the townsfolk, but twisted as only the esteemed Mr. Dark can make them. Can two young boys overcome the worst the devil himself can deal out?
Watch now
2.The Cellar(2022)
6.4HorrorMysteryAlso horror and mystery
When Keira Woods' daughter mysteriously vanishes in the cellar of their new house in the country, she soon discovers there is an ancient and powerful entity controlling their home that she will have to face or risk losing her family's souls forever.
Watch now
3.House on Haunted Hill(1959)
6.7HorrorMysteryAlso horror and mystery
Frederick Loren invites five strangers to the party of a lifetime and offers each of them $10,000 if they can stay the night in the reportedly haunted house. Armed with a gun for protection, each guest arrives in a hearse and will either leave in it much richer…Or dead.
Watch now
5.Night Watch(1973)
6.3MysteryThrillerHorrorAlso mystery and horror
A woman recovering from a nervous breakdown tries to convince her husband and and the local London police that she has witnessed a murder in the abandoned house next door.
Watch now
6.Batman: The Doom That Came to Gotham(2023)
6.7AnimationFantasyActionAlso animation and mystery
Explorer Bruce Wayne accidentally unleashes an ancient evil, and returns to Gotham after being away for two decades. There, Batman battles Lovecraftian supernatural forces and encounters allies and enemies such as Green Arrow, Ra's al Ghul, Mr. Freeze, Killer Croc, Two-Face and James Gordon.
Watch now
7.Circle(2015)
6.0HorrorScience FictionMysteryAlso horror and mystery
In a massive, mysterious chamber, fifty strangers awaken to find themselves trapped with no memory of how they got there. Organized in an inward-facing circle and unable to move, they quickly learn that every two minutes, one of them must die…executed by a strange device in the center of the room.
Watch now
8.The Plague of the Zombies(1966)
6.4HorrorMysteryAlso horror and mystery
Sir James Forbes arrives in a remote Cornish village to identify a mysterious plague afflicting the population. He discovers that one of the squires is a disciple of Haitian witchcraft and using dark magic to resurrect the dead. As the plan to create undead servants unravels, the squire unleashes his zombie army on…
Watch now
9.The House That Dripped Blood(1971)
6.4HorrorMysteryAlso horror and mystery
A Scotland Yard investigator looks into four mysterious cases involving an unoccupied house.
Watch now
10.Next of Kin(1982)
6.2HorrorMysteryAlso horror and mystery
After Linda inherits a retirement home, she witnesses a series of strange events which seem connected to a dark and unspeakable evil.
Watch now
11.The Night Walker(1964)
6.4ThrillerHorrorMysteryAlso horror and mystery
A woman is haunted by recurring nightmares, which seem to be instigated by her late husband who supposedly was killed in a fire.
Watch now
12.The City of the Dead(1960)
6.5MysteryHorrorAlso mystery and horror
In Whitewood, Massachusetts, a presumed witch places a curse on the town before she is burned at the stake. 300 years later, a college student arrives and checks into the mysterious Raven's Inn to research the town's history with witchcraft.
Watch now
13.Murders in the Rue Morgue(1932)
6.0HorrorMysteryCrimeAlso horror and mystery
In 19th century Paris, a maniac abducts young women and injects them with ape blood in an attempt to prove ape-human kinship but constantly meets failure as the abducted women die.
Watch now
14.The Hound of the Baskervilles(1939)
7.1MysteryCrimeHorrorAlso mystery and horror
When a nobleman is threatened by a family curse on his newly inherited estate, detective Sherlock Holmes is hired to investigate.
Watch now
15.The Car(1977)
6.4HorrorActionThrillerAlso horror and mystery
The Utah community of Santa Ynez is being terrorized by a mysterious black coupe that appears out of nowhere and begins running people down. After the car kills off the town sheriff, Captain Wade Parent is determined to stop the murderous driver.
Watch now
16.Fear in the Night(1972)
5.8MysteryThrillerHorrorAlso mystery and horror
It took Peggy Heller a long time to recover from the trauma of a brutal physical assault, suffered in her youth. When she married Robert, he provided her with the love and reassurance she craved for and the two settled down in a pretty house in the grounds of the public school where Robert was a master. But the…
Watch now
17.Mark of the Vampire(1935)
6.2MysteryHorrorAlso mystery and horror
Sir Borotyn, a prominent Prague resident, is discovered murdered in his home, with all indications pointing to a vampiric assault. The victim's friend, Baron Otto, and the physician who analyzes the body, are certain that the vampire is either the mysterious Count Mora or his daughter. Receiving little help from the…
Watch now