If You Liked American Pie, Watch These Next
Finished American Pie (1999) and want more of the same? These 20 movies are what its fans watched next, ranked by how often people who liked it also liked these. Like American Pie, most of them are comedy, romance.
Everything on this page has a home release and plays right here on Rotten Brains — pick one and press play. No sign-up, and a free account only adds resume and history.
20 titles · updated 3rd October 2026
1.Sex and the Teenage Mind(2002)
6.0ComedyAlso comedy
Bumbling high school geek Virgil Heitmeyer has yet to lose his virginity. A golden opportunity for finally getting deflowered arises after Virgil manages to get closer to the beautiful and popular Kellie Guthrie. Will Virgil's date with Kellie go smoothly? Or is Virgil going to blow his big chance to score with the…
Watch now
2.Another Gay Movie(2006)
5.9ComedyRomanceAlso comedy and romance
Andy is your typical All-American eighteen-year-old gay virgin. Like everyone else, he's dying to have sex. Totally out of the closet and mad-crazy horny, this naïve high school senior is caught in that awkward vortex between child and adult. Much to the dismay of his mom (who wonders why all her carrots and…
Watch now
5.The Last American Virgin(1982)
6.6ComedyAlso comedy
The friendship of a group of young friends struggling with teen sex, drugs, and work is jeopardized by a romantic interest which may turn pals into bitter rivals.
Watch now
6.Just One of the Guys(1985)
6.4ComedyRomanceAlso comedy and romance
When Terry Griffith loses her high school's writing competition, she's convinced that it's because she's a girl. So Terry decides to change high schools and pose as a boy to prove her point. Her brother, Buddy, helps her pass as a guy so well that she is soon making friends with the boys at school, including the…
Watch now
7.The 40 Year-Old Virgin(2005)
6.4ComedyRomanceAlso comedy and romance
Andy Stitzer has a pleasant life with a nice apartment and a job stamping invoices at an electronics store. But at age 40, there's one thing Andy hasn't done, and it's really bothering his sex-obsessed male co-workers: Andy is still a virgin. Determined to help Andy get laid, the guys make it their mission to…
Watch now
8.I Love You, Beth Cooper(2009)
6.1ComedyRomanceAlso comedy and romance
A valedictorian's declaration of love for a high-school cheerleader launches a night of revelry, reflection and romance for a group of graduating seniors.
Watch now
9.The Girl Next Door(2004)
6.8ComedyRomanceAlso comedy and romance
Exceptionally ambitious high schooler Matthew has aspirations for a career in politics when he falls in love with his gorgeous 19-year-old neighbor, Danielle. But Matthew's bright future is jeopardized when he finds Danielle was once a porn star. As Danielle's past catches up with her, Matthew's love for her forces…
Watch now
10.Not Another Teen Movie(2001)
5.8ComedyAlso comedy
On a bet, a gridiron hero at John Hughes High School sets out to turn a bespectacled plain Jane into a beautiful and popular prom queen in this outrageous send-up of the teen movies of the 1980s and '90s.
Watch now
11.Saved!(2004)
6.4ComedyAlso comedy
Mary is a good Christian girl who goes to a good Christian high school where she has good Christian friends and a perfect Christian boyfriend. Her life seems perfect, until the day that she finds out that her boyfriend may be gay — and that she’s pregnant.
Watch now
14.No Hard Feelings(2023)
6.7ComedyRomanceAlso comedy and romance
On the brink of losing her childhood home, Maddie discovers an intriguing job listing: wealthy helicopter parents looking for someone to “date” their introverted 19-year-old son, Percy, before he leaves for college. To her surprise, Maddie soon discovers the awkward Percy is no sure thing.
Watch now
15.The Last Summer(2019)
6.0RomanceComedyAlso romance and comedy
Standing on the precipice of adulthood, a group of friends navigate new relationships, while reexamining others, during their final summer before college.
Watch now
16.Do Revenge(2022)
6.4ComedyThrillerRomanceAlso comedy and romance
A dethroned queen bee at a posh private high school strikes a secret deal with an unassuming new student to enact revenge on one another’s enemies.
Watch now
17.Road Trip(2000)
6.3ComedyAdventureAlso comedy
After a student at the University of Ithaca films his one-night stand with a beautiful sorority girl, he discovers one of his friends has accidentally mailed the homemade sex tape to his girlfriend in Austin. In a frenzy, he must borrow a car and hit the road in a desperate bid to intercept the tape.
Watch now
18.The Moon Is Blue(1953)
6.3ComedyRomanceAlso comedy and romance
Two aging playboys are both after the same attractive young woman, but she fends them off by claiming that she plans to remain a virgin until her wedding night. Both men determine to find a way around her objections.
Watch now
19.Booksmart(2019)
7.0ComedyAlso comedy
Two academic teenage superstars realize, on the eve of their high school graduation, that they should have worked less and played more. Determined to never fall short of their peers, the girls set out on a mission to cram four years of fun into one night.
Watch now